Series 1 | Article 3 of 3
The Three Questions That Changed the Way I Think About Difficult Decisions
Over the past couple of weeks, I've written about why becoming a Registered Manager isn't just about learning new tasks. It's about learning to think differently.
In my last article, I promised to share the simple decision-making framework that's shaped the way I've coached and developed Registered Managers over many years. If I'm honest, calling it a framework probably makes it sound grander than it really is. It isn't a script nor is it a checklist. It's simply a way of making sure I don't become so focused on one consequence that I forget the others.
Many years ago, I worked with an owner whose meetings always seemed to follow the same pattern. He never introduced it as a leadership model or a decision-making framework. In fact, I don't think he even realised he was teaching it. It was simply the way he approached difficult conversations. Whether we were discussing a customer, a staffing issue, quality concerns or the future of the service, our conversations always seemed to come back to three themes: People, Quality & Growth.
Looking back now, I realise just how much that influenced the way I think today. When I'm coaching Registered Managers, I don't ask the same questions every time. That wouldn't make sense. Every manager is different, every situation is different and every conversation deserves different questions.
The questions themselves change - The three themes don't.
People, Quality, Growth.
One conversation that has stayed with me came from a Registered Manager who came to me because she wanted to serve notice on a customer's package of care. The relationship had become incredibly difficult and the carers had reached the point where they simply didn't feel able to continue.
Carers, by their very nature, are caring people. They don't choose this profession because the hours are easy or because it's particularly well paid. They do it because they genuinely want to make a difference. That's why deciding to walk away from a customer is never something good carers do lightly. In my experience, by the time they've reached that point, they've often been carrying that burden for far longer than anyone has realised.
The Registered Manager asked me a simple question.
"What do you think I should do?"
I didn't give her the answer. Instead, I said,
"Talk me through your options."
Because my role was never to make the decision for her.
It was still her name above the door.
If she genuinely believed continuing the package of care was no longer safe or posed a risk to her registration, I wasn't going to tell her she couldn't serve notice because we'd lose the revenue. My role was different. My role was to help her make that decision having considered every important angle.
So we worked through each option. Who would it affect? Not just the customer, but their family, the carers, the office team and partner professionals. What did it mean from a quality and compliance perspective? Were we following the correct process? Had every reasonable alternative been explored? What could we learn from the situation? And finally...How would it affect the future of the service? Its capacity. Its sustainability. Its reputation. Its commercial performance.
The interesting thing is...She still decided to serve notice. The conversation hadn't been about changing her decision. It had been about helping her reach that decision having considered the people involved, the quality of the service and the future of the organisation and making sure she considered all the relevant steps she would need to take.
That's what I mean by thinking differently. Not making decisions more complicated. Making sure they're more considered. Over the years, I've asked hundreds of different questions because every manager and every situation has been different.
But if you've genuinely asked yourself a good question around People, Quality and Growth before making an important decision, I don't think you'll go far wrong.
Have you developed your own way of slowing down difficult decisions? Or has someone in your career quietly shaped the way you think without ever realising it?
And if you'd like to develop confident managers who make balanced, well-considered decisions, I'd genuinely love to have a conversation.